Their five demands. Our five responses. Side by side.
01
No Rajya Sabha for retired CJI
If CJP comes to power, no Chief Justice shall be granted a Rajya Sabha seat as a post-retirement reward.
01
Disagreement — with safeguards
Permit with cooling-off period
Retired judges carry decades of field wisdom no electoral process produces. Permit appointments with a three-year cooling-off period and clearance by an independent eligibility panel. Honour earned through service is honoured through utility, not retirement.
02
UAPA on the CEC
If any legit vote is deleted, the Chief Election Commissioner shall be arrested under UAPA. Taking away voting rights is no less than terrorism.
02
Disagreement — on viveka
Reject UAPA, narrow remedy
UAPA against the Election Commissioner legitimises the very instrument of state overreach the opposition rightly criticises. Adharma cannot be answered with adharma. Criminal liability for vote suppression under specific election-law provisions, investigated by an independent panel.
03
50% women's reservation
50% reservation for women, not 33%, without increasing the strength of Parliament. 50% of all Cabinet positions reserved for women.
03
Tactical agreement — stated openly
Accept now, dismantle the need
Tactical agreement, not principled. Mandated quotas eventually produce tokens. Long vision: dismantle every structural barrier to candidacy — for women, backward classes, economically suppressed sectors — until reservation becomes unnecessary.
04
Cancel Ambani/Adani media licences
All media houses owned by Ambani and Adani shall have their licences cancelled. Bank accounts of Godi media anchors investigated.
04
Position pending
No public stance yet
We do not yet have sufficient evidence to take a public stance. We will publish one when we do. Performing certainty we do not have is the failure mode we refuse.
05
20-year ban on defectors
Any MLA or MP who defects shall be barred from contesting elections — and from any public office — for 20 years.
05
Disagreement — on viveka
Punish corruption, not conscience
A blanket ban confuses changing one's mind with selling one's seat. Permit defection. Every defection triggers a mandatory anti-corruption investigation. Conviction evolution is protected. Conviction selling is punished.